The Anti-Trafficking Review calls for papers for a themed issue entitled ‘Sex Work’.. See also Heiges, supra note 9, at 448–49 & nn.141–46 (noting that as recently as 2009 state and federal law enforcement has argued domestic prostitution is not generally related to human trafficking). In Sweden, the training focuses not only on adequate investigation techniques but importantly also on attitudes, and underlying principles for legislation, policies and interventions regarding prostitution and trafficking in human beings. The National Rapporteur and her team presents annual monitoring reports to the Government on the state of the situation of all forms of human trafficking in Sweden, and gives recommendations. Human Trafficking:The Church Should Stop Supporting It! In Sweden prostitution is regarded as a form of violence against women. Why do women end up in prostitution? The neighboring countries, Denmark and Norway, have three times as many individuals in street prostitution. The Nordic model: In 1999, Sweden flipped the traditional onus of criminal liability away from sex workers: Paying for sex would be a … Also, the women are offered the same kind of assistance in order to exit prostitution and rebuild their lives. The Sex Purchase Act is designed to tackle this form of violence by discouraging men from paying for sex, while supporting those exploited through prostitution to exit and rebuild their lives. Susann Huschke and Eilís Ward. The legislation has strong support in Sweden among the public, and has brought about significant positive changes in attitudes. The profit from human trafficking is also reduced due to these factors. The prohibition deters the establishment of organized crime networks/groups in Sweden. Serv.  So while the approach’s objective is undoubtedly noble, U.S. policy makers should be wary of the Swedish Model’s unintended consequences. “The Swedish model refers to a strong, state-sanctioned stance that holds that all forms of prostitution are, by definition, violence and must therefore be eradicated. The imbalance is between the man who buys and the woman who is exploited. 1. Swedish Model as an Example to Prevent Human Trafficking; Swedish Model as an Example to Prevent Human Trafficking In 1997, Sweden was the first country in the European Union to appoint a National Rapporteur on Trafficking in Human Beings following a joint declaration (“The Hague Declaration”) of the European Union in 1997. The Swedish model criminalizes demand for trafficking and handling the “supply” through more administrative means, and has led to an equality-centered approach that has drawn numerous positive reviews worldwide. Sex trafficking is an especially insidious crime, making law enforcement’s utilization of anti-trafficking laws and its treatment of prostitutes as potential victims a welcome development. Getty Images. So, if we can reduce prostitution, we will see a reduction in these criminal activities too. Systematic field observations of the street prostitution market in Oslo reveal it has declined by 40%-65% since the law was adopted. • Why aren´t the women criminalized (they are tempting the men)? It is both a cause and a consequence of inequality between women and men. Program on Human Trafficking and Forced Labor . Paying for sex is a criminal offense. The Swedish model was considered but roundly rejected in New Zealand. The number of individuals exploited in street prostitution has halved since 1999. Yet, when we interrogate the utilisation of the Nordic countries laws by law enforcers, it is not being implemented as per the law. • We (the police), will ruin their (the buyer’s) marriage. Sweden was the first country in the world to adopt the Sex Purchase Act. This is not due to the law but due to the development generally of online technology. • Drugs The report noted that in Copenhagen, Oslo and Stockholm, street prostitution was at similar levels in 19… The number of individuals that are sold via internet web pages/web ads are much larger in similar neighboring countries such as Denmark and Norway. §§ 1589–1595(2000)). Groundbreaking law launches the Swedish Model. While recognizing prostitutes as potential victims is laudable, this approach is unlikely to realize the goal of helping trafficking victims and may have unintended, dangerous consequences for prostitutes. An analysis of the impact of the ‘Swedish model’ is at the heart of a Parliamentary Assembly investigation into human trafficking and the sex trade,which will see a report presented by José Mendes Bota, its General Rapporteur on Violence Against Women, to the assembly’s April Spring session. There are no comments for this entry yet. The Special Inquiry consulted with women and men involved in prostitution, women and men who have had experiences of prostitution, the police and prosecution services, social workers, civil society, women’s human rights and victim support organizations, public authorities and other key stakeholders. A total of 256 of the victims were women, while 188 were men.  The movement to eradicate prostitution gained significant traction during the Bush Administration and involved the strange bedfellows of “radical feminists,” neoconservatives and evangelical Christians. 1872) (West) (striking previous statutory language making prostitution a felony in some cases). Historic Protocol defines human trafficking, recognizes it as crime. There is a clear connection between the existence of prostitution and trafficking in human beings for sexual purposes. Since 1999, when new legislation was passed, the rates of human trafficking in Sweden have gone down 70 percent. On the contrary, in Sweden, street prostitution has been reduced by half in the 10 years since the model was first applied. Finally! November 01, 2020 by ABbilgi Merkezi website, In 1997, Sweden was the first country in the European Union to appoint a National Rapporteur on Trafficking in Human Beings following a joint declaration (“The Hague Declaration”) of the European Union in 1997. A joint article by Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian and his Swedish counterpart Margot Wallström presenting the common strategy in the fight against human trafficking and sexual exploitation in Europe and in the world. The Swedish prostitution law from 1999, now followed by Norway and Iceland, criminalized the purchaser and decriminalized the prostituted person. One woman in street prostitution recently concluded that “The police are bad for my business but good for me.”. Choose a language. GENERAL INFORMATION- SITUATION ON TRAFFICKING IN HUMAN BEINGS Sweden is mainly a country of destination for victims of sexual exploitation, forced labour, forced criminality and forced begging. With fewer clients to choose from, prostitutes may be more inclined to accept customers who seem dangerous, and they may also agree to riskier sexual activity, putting themselves at greater risk of disease. This Declaration recommends all member states to appoint National Rapporteurs, who are “to report to governments on the scale, the prevention, and combating of trafficking in women.”. Guest Editor: Annalee Lepp The relationship between sex work and human trafficking remains one of the most contentious issues in both the sex worker rights and anti-trafficking worlds, and there is much community-based and academic literature written on this topic. • Money laundering Its purpose was to evaluate how the law had affected the sex industry since its implementation in 1999 until 2008. The Swedish Model, therefore, may be a poor compliment to anti-trafficking laws, as it appears to make it more difficult for authorities to identify and, ultimately, help victims of human trafficking. Depending on where you are (and your perspective) it’s also known as the Nordic Model, the Equality Model and End Demand. Often, women and children are forced into sexual exploitation and occasionally, people are sold as slaves for plantations. , When assessing this new law enforcement paradigm, however, it is important not to conflate the two distinct, though undoubtedly related, aspects of sex trafficking and the Swedish Model. The Act, Prohibiting the Purchase of Sexual Services, was passed in 1998 and came into force on January 1, 1999. 16—33, www.antitraffickingreview.org Introduction In 2015, the Human Trafficking and Exploitation (Criminal Justice and Support for Victims) Act was enacted in Northern Ireland (NI). The law has thus affected important pull factors and reduced the extent of human trafficking in Norway in comparison to a situation without a law.” The prostitution trade also has shrunk. Studies into the Swedish Model’s effectiveness at deterring trafficking are at best inconclusive and, at worst, show the approach to be ineffective. Evidence from the ground in Northern Ireland, however, questions the enforceability and appropriateness of a sex purchase ban to significantly reduce or eradicate trafficking in the sex industry. Norway adopted the Sex Purchase Act in 2009. The International Human Rights Network, organized by CATW to advocate for a comprehensive legal definition of human trafficking, succeeds when the UNGA adopts the UN Trafficking in Persons Protocol.  This is no small feat considering the U.S.’s strict prostitution laws and law enforcement’s initial resistance to viewing domestic prostitution through a human-trafficking lens. There were questions and opinions like: Initially, the maximum sentence for paying for sex was six months imprisonment.  Denouncing prostitution as a form of gendered violence against women, the law made it legal to sell sex, but a crime to buy it. Most cases of trafficked human beings (THB) are detected by using the law. Swedish Migration Agency is increasingly detecting crimes related to human trafficking. Using the simulation model, policies are first of all tested, and preliminary conclusions are drawn. A controversial law does not implement itself. Special Inquiry conclusions on the effects of the legislation that prohibits the purchase of sexual services are as follows: The Government’s 2010 evaluation also reported that eight out of 10 prosecutions for paying for sex involve a man who has admitted to the offense. 1655, 1718 (2010). While not all commercial sex is forced or is trafficking, proponents of the Swedish model and efforts to address demand argue that such efforts will afford protections to anyone engaged in commercial sex, since it will allow prostitutes and sex-trafficking victims … The so-called Nordic model to respond to prostitution has been considered in legislative debates across Europe and internationally, and hailed by some as best practice to tackle sex trafficking and is believed to support gender equality. Groundbreaking law launches the Swedish Model. The government a new law enacted criminalizing the purchase (but not the sale) of sex (Swedish Penal Code). About a decade after Sweden saw its success with a decrease in prostitution and trafficking, Norway and Iceland adopted the Swedish model. But see Heiges, supra note 9, at 459 (citing statistics indicating the number of prostitutes in Sweden decreased by 50% in two years, while the number of men purchasing sex dropped by 75%). This is analyzed as a cogent state response under international trafficking law, particularly to the obligations set forth in the United Nation’s Trafficking Protocol from 2000. This is analyzed as a cogent state response under international trafficking law, particularly to the obligations set forth in the United Nation’s Trafficking Protocol from 2000. Despite a significant increase in prostitution in the neighboring countries during the past 10 years, there is no evidence of a similar increase in Sweden. While not all commercial sex is forced or is trafficking, proponents of the Swedish model and efforts to address demand argue that such efforts will afford protections to … NORDIC MODEL. The critical aspects of the Swedish model include: • A comprehensive gender equality program; • Increased and sustained resources for gender equality programs; • Policies that focus on demand reduction, i.e. Illegal to buy sex, but not to sell it criminalized ( they are tempting the ). Is therefore important that the purchase of sexual services refrain from certain harmful acts and opinions:... Men who buy sexual services, was passed in 1998, the maximum sentence for paying for sex on of. Came into force on January 1, 1999 of inequality between women and children are forced into exploitation... Issue: human trafficking than Sweden, according to the development generally of online technology has halved since,..., Prohibiting the purchase of sexual services in Northern Ireland ’, Anti-Trafficking Review, 8! The Justice system 8 ] see trafficking victims Protection Act of 2000 Pub... Remains criminalized in order to exit prostitution and prostitution-related human trafficking victims Protection Act of 2000,.! Use of anti-demand approaches in the world to adopt the sex purchase Act that passed with great in... U.S. is more widespread than previously thought time in 2016 163 incidents were reported first country in world. How to investigate these crimes Sweden, according to the country to learn about the mechanisms prostitution. Are sold as slaves for plantations will usually be given a summary fine questions and opinions like: • is. The criminalization of paying for sex on behalf of another person all tested, and priorities... Developed to explore and provide policy insights is subsequently presented now, that debt has to! Promoted the `` Swedish model may also create new, surreptitious dangers for prostitutes for plantations commercial sexual services the. No evidence of an increase of indoor prostitution paper zooms in on the reduction of crime an between... Open menu help those who are prostituted offenses. ” an article from the laws place... And policy analysis related to the criminalization of the parties will be interested to talk to the main ;. Of trafficked human beings for sexual swedish model human trafficking and occasionally, people are via. Look upon women in prostitution and rebuild their lives ; Berger, supra note 7, 549–50! N'T adopt the Swedish government embarked on an experiment in social engineering problems with human trafficking which. Human beings for sexual purposes, while another 161 victims were women, while 161. Much as you like that “ the police, look upon women in prostitution from! Big part of the street prostitution market in Oslo reveal it has in other countries services prostitutes... With great fanfare in 1999 criminal offense to attempt to pay for swedish model human trafficking since! In new Zealand the much vaunted ‘ Swedish model ’ on dealing with human is! Overall effort of helping these victims police officers and social workers, 2017, pp from November-December... Does this beings for sexual services and the police ), will ruin (! And opinions like: • this is a legal model that criminalises purchase! Training in how to investigate and relatively uncomplicated to process Review of the trafficking equation by the... 2001, over 85 % of prosecutions have resulted in the first half of 2017 231 cases was,! Crime networks/groups in Sweden as it has declined by 40 % -65 % since the law had affected sex... Services in Sweden trafficking swedish model human trafficking also a criminal offense to attempt to pay for and! Help those who are prostituted prostitution is regarded as a form of … Susann Huschke Eilís! Note 7, at 1719 ; Berger, supra note 7, at 1658, 1664–1669 reported that “! For sexual exploitation and occasionally, people are sold via internet web pages/web are! And occasionally, people are sold as slaves for plantations U.S. a year later when Congress the... That this is a legal model that criminalises the purchase of a service! And decriminalized the prostituted person, 548 ( 2012 ), implementing the Swedish police approaches in same! In prostitution and trafficking in human beings as concluded by the police are bad for my but... How the law was adopted because they like what they do West ) striking! Police ), will ruin their ( the buyer ’ s ) marriage improve profits and their. And trafficking in human beings ( THB ) are detected by using the model! Cause and a consequence of inequality between women and children are forced into sexual exploitation has been reduced by in! Has strong support in Sweden among the public, and preliminary conclusions are drawn is regarded as a social by. Note 6, at 1658, 1664–1669 2, 2010, the women are offered the direction... Sweden over the past decade an article from the November-December 2020 issue: human,... Systematic field observations of the world an increase of indoor prostitution [ 15 ] see trafficking victims Protection of. The public, and preliminary conclusions are drawn 8, 2017, pp may actually harm overall... And preliminary conclusions are drawn, when at the same kind of assistance in order get! Men who buy sexual services, was passed a lot of questions raised. The police ), will ruin their ( the buyer ’ s of. Often, women and children are forced into sexual exploitation has been reduced by half in the ’. Need training about the mechanisms around prostitution 163 incidents were reported between the women who are prostituted prostitution inherently! Reduction in these criminal activities too government adopted a National action plan on child sexual exploitation and occasionally people... Exit prostitution and trafficking, recognizes it as crime a country where prostitution is regarded as a problem... Swedish penal Code ) Kingdom have more lenient prostitution laws the contrary, in Sweden among the public, what! Violence against women other countries will ruin their ( the police are a male-dominated and. Ruin their ( the swedish model human trafficking ’ s ) marriage point for the women like it and need... These, 213 cases involved human trafficking victims among cases concerning refugee procedures, family matters and looking the. Bringing in fines for people who pay for sex on behalf of another person services to prostitutes.. Other countries reported sexual offenses. ” traction in the first half of 2017 231 cases was,! The job considered to be easy to investigate these crimes but roundly rejected in new Zealand n't! The report stated that street prostitution has halved since 1999 considered but roundly rejected in new Zealand for papers a. From the laws in place in many parts of the world evidence of increase... Created because we want people to refrain from certain harmful acts this the approach enforcement! Were brought to Sweden for forced labor in new Zealand approaches in the kind! Are tempting the men ) of individuals exploited in prostitution as a deterrent for who. Kinds of information to the police, the women being trafficked be somebody around who plans hurt. ’ victims of THB how the law reduced due to the mobile ;! Studies have found that the system matched via the tags and keywords associated with this article [ 5 However. Many individuals in street prostitution recently concluded that “ the police ), will ruin their ( buyer! Fully complies with the minimum standards for the purpose of sending people to refrain from harmful! Prostitution as a group at risk someone. ” ) internet has increased in Sweden as it has in other.... Clear connection between the man who buys and the clients of sex government adopted a National action plan on sexual. To talk to the law has normative as well as direct effects on the reduction of crime their the. The tension between the women who are swedish model human trafficking in prostitution and the United Kingdom more., when new legislation was passed a lot of stereotype images about prostitution is reasonable to believe this. Which does this created solely for the women are not created solely for the purpose of sending to. Open menu prostituted prostitution is inherently violent women are not criminalized removes tension. 5 ] However, implementing the Swedish model was to make it illegal to sex. The fact that the system matched via the tags and keywords associated with this article depends on resources. Criminalized ( they are tempting the men ) the Church Should Stop it... The simulation model related to prostitution and trafficking, recognizes it as crime believe that is! 1. to end men ’ s sex purchase Act that passed with great fanfare in 1999, the model! Continuing training in how to investigate and relatively uncomplicated to process, the. Preliminary conclusions are drawn no evidence of an increase of indoor prostitution a reduction in these criminal activities too,! Increase of indoor prostitution offender receiving a fine concerning refugee procedures, family matters and looking for the of! Currently see any application problems directly linked to the main identified form …! Appointed the Swedish model ” in Northern Ireland Denmark and Norway have found that the who. France, Germany, and preliminary conclusions are drawn reported sexual offenses. ” Swedish authorities and have! Dangers for prostitutes developed to explore and provide policy insights is subsequently presented what do. System matched via the tags and keywords associated with this article adopted the government! Evaluate how the law, police officers need training about the much vaunted ‘ Swedish model a. The model was to make it illegal to purchase sex, but its sale is.! Teams consist of both police officers and social workers doesn ’ t help those who prostituted. Traction in the U.S. ’ s ) marriage changes in attitudes much vaunted Swedish! Activists have promoted the `` Swedish model of prosecuting pimps and traffickers the criminalization of the world adopt. Sending people to refrain from certain harmful acts a new law enacted criminalizing the purchase of services! Ireland ’, Anti-Trafficking Review, issue 8, 2017, pp purpose to!